AI Productivity
Stuck Between Two Options? Make AI Ask You 3 Questions First
Can't choose between two options? Have an AI chatbot ask you three questions about what matters, compare both options against your answers, then argue for the one you're leaning against.
Two laptops. Two job offers. Two courses, two flats, two weekend plans. When you ask an AI "which one should I pick?", you usually get a generic pros-and-cons list that could apply to anyone.
The fix is simple: make the AI ask you what matters before it compares anything. Here's how to do it in a few minutes.
Step 1: Name both options in one line
Open a chatbot such as ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Claude or Microsoft Copilot and state the choice plainly. Leave out private details you don't need to share:
I'm choosing between Option A: [short description] and Option B: [short description].
Step 2: Tell it to ask before it answers
This is the important part. Add:
Before you compare them, ask me 3 questions about what matters most to me. Then wait for my answers.
Good questions are about your situation: your budget, your timeline, what you'll use it for, what you'd regret. Answer honestly and briefly.
Step 3: Get a comparison built on your answers
Once you've replied, ask:
Now compare both options against my answers only. Show it as a short table, then tell me which one fits better and why.
Because the comparison uses your priorities, it's far more useful than a generic list.
Step 4: Ask it to argue the other side
Most of us lean one way before we start. Test that lean:
Now make the strongest case for the option I seem to be leaning against.
If that argument doesn't change your mind, you can be more confident. If it does, you've found something worth thinking about.
Step 5: Find out what would change the answer
Finish with:
What one fact, if I found it out, would change your recommendation?
That gives you a clear next step, such as checking a price, a contract term or a review, before you decide.
Decisions this works for
- Buying: two phones, laptops or appliances (then check real specs and prices on the seller's site).
- Study and work: two courses, two projects to focus on, or two ways to spend your week.
- Everyday plans: two trip ideas, two gym schedules, or two ways to split chores at home.
- Bigger choices: two job offers or two places to live, as a way to organise your thinking.
Know the limits
The AI only knows what you tell it, and it can get facts wrong, especially prices, specs and dates. Check important details at the original source. For money, legal, medical or other high-stakes decisions, use this to organise your thoughts and then talk to a qualified person. The decision stays yours.
The takeaway
Next time you're stuck, open any AI chat and type: "I'm choosing between [A] and [B]. Before you compare them, ask me 3 questions about what matters most to me. Then wait." Answer, get the comparison, then ask it to argue for the option you're leaning against.
Want more ways to make AI ask before it answers? Read Make AI Ask Before It Drafts Your Email. Facing a tough talk about your decision? See Practice a Hard Conversation With AI Before You Have It.
Save this for your next tough choice, share it with someone who's stuck deciding, and like & follow @ai_tools_day for more AI tips.